| First Quarter |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | NYJ | Mia |
| Mia | | | Dan Carpenter kicks off to the NYJ0. Touchback. | | |
| NYJ | 1st&10 | NYJ20 | Mark Sanchez incomplete pass to the right intended for Stephen Hill. | | |
| NYJ | 2nd&10 | NYJ20 | Shonn Greene rush to the right for 2 yards to the NYJ22. Tackled by Karlos Dansby. | | |
| NYJ | 3rd&8 | NYJ22 | Penalty: Pass Interference on Miami (Nolan Carroll) 14 yards. | | |
| NYJ | 1st&10 | NYJ36 | Mark Sanchez pass to the middle to Shonn Greene for 3 yards to the NYJ39. Tackled by Karlos Dansby. | | |
| NYJ | 2nd&7 | NYJ39 | Mark Sanchez pass intended for Clyde Gates INTERCEPTED by Richard Marshall and returned for 7 yards. Tackled by Clyde Gates. | | |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | NYJ | Mia |
| Mia | 1st&10 | NYJ47 | Ryan Tannehill pass to the left to Anthony Fasano for 3 yards to the NYJ44. Tackled by Calvin Pace. | | |
| Mia | 2nd&7 | NYJ44 | Reggie Bush rush to the left for 6 yards to the NYJ38. Tackled by Mike DeVito and Bart Scott. | | |
| Mia | 3rd&1 | NYJ38 | Jorvorskie Lane rush to the right for 3 yards to the NYJ35. Tackled by Sione Po'uha. | | |
| Mia | 1st&10 | NYJ35 | Ryan Tannehill pass to the left to Anthony Fasano for 9 yards to the NYJ26. Tackled by David Harris. | | |
| Mia | 2nd&1 | NYJ26 | Reggie Bush rush to the left for 16 yards to the NYJ10. Tackled by Darrelle Revis. | | |
| Mia | 1st&10 | NYJ10 | Reggie Bush rush up the middle for 7 yards to the NYJ3. Tackled by Darrelle Revis. | | |
| Mia | 2nd&3 | NYJ3 | Reggie Bush rush to the right for 2 yards to the NYJ1. Tackled by Muhammad Wilkerson. | | |
| Mia | 3rd&1 | NYJ1 | Daniel Thomas rush up the middle for 1 yard for a TOUCHDOWN. | | |
| Mia | | | Dan Carpenter extra point is good. | | |
| Mia | | | Drive Stats: 8 plays, 47 yards, 4min 6sec | 0 | 7 |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | NYJ | Mia |
| Mia | | | Dan Carpenter kicks off to the NYJ0. Joe McKnight return for 24 yards to NYJ19. Tackled by Austin Spitler and R.J. Stanford. | | |
| NYJ | 1st&10 | NYJ19 | Shonn Greene rush to the left for no gain to the NYJ19. Tackled by Reshad Jones. | | |
| NYJ | 2nd&10 | NYJ19 | Penalty: Illegal Contact on Miami (Sean Smith) 5 yards. | | |
| NYJ | 1st&10 | NYJ24 | Shonn Greene rush to the right for 6 yards to the NYJ30. Tackled by Chris Clemons. | | |
| NYJ | 2nd&4 | NYJ30 | Shonn Greene rush to the left for 3 yards to the NYJ33. Tackled by Koa Misi and Kevin Burnett. | | |
| NYJ | 3rd&1 | NYJ33 | Mark Sanchez pass to the right to Konrad Reuland for 2 yards to the NYJ35. Tackled by Karlos Dansby. | | |
| NYJ | 1st&10 | NYJ35 | Mark Sanchez incomplete pass to the left intended for Jeremy Kerley. | | |
| NYJ | 2nd&10 | NYJ35 | Shonn Greene rush to the right for 4 yards to the NYJ39. Tackled by Karlos Dansby. | | |
| NYJ | 3rd&6 | NYJ39 | Miami Dolphins timeout. | | |
| NYJ | 3rd&6 | NYJ39 | Mark Sanchez incomplete pass to the right intended for Stephen Hill defensed by Sean Smith. | | |
| NYJ | 4th&6 | NYJ39 | Robert Malone punts for 54 yards to Mia7. Marcus Thigpen return for 1 yard to Mia8. Tackled by Demario Davis. Penalty: Illegal Block on Miami (Nolan Carroll) -3 yards. | | |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | NYJ | Mia |
| Mia | 1st&10 | Mia5 | Reggie Bush rush to the right for 7 yards to the Mia12. Tackled by LaRon Landry. | | |
| Mia | 2nd&3 | Mia12 | Reggie Bush rush to the left for 12 yards to the Mia24. Tackled by Darrelle Revis and Yeremiah Bell. | | |
| Mia | 1st&10 | Mia24 | Ryan Tannehill incomplete pass to the right intended for Davone Bess. | | |
| Mia | 2nd&10 | Mia24 | Ryan Tannehill pass to the left to Anthony Armstrong for 9 yards to the Mia33. Tackled by Darrelle Revis. | | |
| Mia | 3rd&1 | Mia33 | Ryan Tannehill incomplete pass to the right intended for Daniel Thomas. | | |
| Mia | 4th&1 | Mia33 | Brandon Fields punts for 57 yards to NYJ10. Jeremy Kerley return for 18 yards to NYJ28. Tackled by Nolan Carroll. Penalty: Illegal Block on New York (Joe McKnight) -10 yards. | | |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | NYJ | Mia |
| NYJ | 1st&10 | NYJ18 | Bilal Powell rush up the middle for 4 yards to the NYJ22. Tackled by Kevin Burnett. | | |
| NYJ | 2nd&6 | NYJ22 | Mark Sanchez pass to the middle to Bilal Powell for 10 yards to the NYJ32. Tackled by Karlos Dansby. | | |
| NYJ | 1st&10 | NYJ32 | Penalty: Illegal Contact on Miami (Richard Marshall) 5 yards. | | |
| NYJ | 1st&10 | NYJ37 | Bilal Powell rush up the middle for 4 yards to the NYJ41. Tackled by Jared Odrick. | | |
| NYJ | 2nd&6 | NYJ41 | Mark Sanchez pass to the right to Konrad Reuland for 10 yards to the Mia49. Tackled by Sean Smith. | | |
| NYJ | 1st&10 | Mia49 | Bilal Powell rush to the right for no gain to the Mia49. Tackled by Koa Misi. | | |
| |
| Second Quarter |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | NYJ | Mia |
| NYJ | 2nd&10 | Mia49 | Mark Sanchez incomplete pass to the left intended for Stephen Hill. | | |
| NYJ | 3rd&10 | Mia49 | Mark Sanchez sacked at NYJ45 for a loss of 6 yards by Jared Odrick and Olivier Vernon. | | |
| NYJ | 4th&16 | NYJ45 | Robert Malone punts for 43 yards to Mia12. Davone Bess return for 10 yards to Mia22. Tackled by Nick Bellore. | | |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | NYJ | Mia |
| Mia | 1st&10 | Mia22 | Daniel Thomas rush to the left for 3 yards to the Mia25. Tackled by Muhammad Wilkerson. | | |
| Mia | 2nd&7 | Mia25 | Daniel Thomas rush to the left for 4 yards to the Mia29. Tackled by David Harris. | | |
| Mia | 3rd&3 | Mia29 | Miami Dolphins timeout. | | |
| Mia | 3rd&3 | Mia29 | Penalty: Illegal Contact on New York (Bart Scott) 5 yards. | | |
| Mia | 1st&10 | Mia34 | Reggie Bush rush to the left for 4 yards to the Mia38. Tackled by David Harris. | | |
| Mia | 2nd&6 | Mia38 | Ryan Tannehill pass to the left to Reggie Bush for 1 yard to the Mia39. Tackled by Darrelle Revis. | | |
| Mia | 3rd&5 | Mia39 | Ryan Tannehill pass to the right to Davone Bess for 23 yards to the NYJ38. Tackled by David Harris. | | |
| Mia | 1st&10 | NYJ38 | Ryan Tannehill pass to the right to Anthony Fasano for 17 yards to the NYJ21. Tackled by Antonio Cromartie. | | |
| Mia | 1st&10 | NYJ21 | Daniel Thomas rush to the right for 4 yards to the NYJ17. Tackled by Yeremiah Bell. | | |
| Mia | 2nd&6 | NYJ17 | Ryan Tannehill incomplete pass to the right intended for Brian Hartline. | | |
| Mia | 3rd&6 | NYJ17 | Daniel Thomas rush up the middle for 6 yards to the NYJ11. Tackled by LaRon Landry. | | |
| Mia | 1st&10 | NYJ11 | Daniel Thomas rush to the left for 7 yards to the NYJ4. Tackled by Sione Po'uha. | | |
| Mia | 2nd&3 | NYJ4 | Daniel Thomas rush to the left for 1 yard to the NYJ3. Tackled by Calvin Pace. | | |
| Mia | 3rd&2 | NYJ3 | Ryan Tannehill incomplete pass to the right intended for Brian Hartline. | | |
| Mia | 4th&2 | NYJ3 | Dan Carpenter 21 yard field goal attempt is GOOD. Holder: Brandon Fields. | | |
| Mia | | | Drive Stats: 13 plays, 75 yards, 5min 48sec | 0 | 10 |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | NYJ | Mia |
| Mia | | | Dan Carpenter kicks off to the NYJ3. Joe McKnight return for 15 yards to NYJ18. Tackled by Legedu Naanee. | | |
| NYJ | 1st&10 | NYJ18 | Mark Sanchez incomplete pass to the right intended for Stephen Hill. | | |
| NYJ | 2nd&10 | NYJ18 | Penalty: False Start on New York (Austin Howard) -5 yards. | | |
| NYJ | 2nd&15 | NYJ13 | Mark Sanchez incomplete pass to the right intended for Santonio Holmes defensed by Karlos Dansby. | | |
| NYJ | 3rd&15 | NYJ13 | Mark Sanchez pass to the right to Santonio Holmes for 12 yards to the NYJ25. Tackled by Chris Clemons. | | |
| NYJ | 4th&3 | NYJ25 | Tim Tebow rush to the left for 5 yards to the NYJ30. Tackled by Olivier Vernon. | | |
| NYJ | 1st&10 | NYJ30 | Mark Sanchez incomplete pass to the right intended for Jeff Cumberland. | | |
| NYJ | 2nd&10 | NYJ30 | Mark Sanchez incomplete pass to the left intended for Santonio Holmes. | | |
| NYJ | 3rd&10 | NYJ30 | Mark Sanchez pass to the middle to Santonio Holmes for 15 yards to the NYJ45. Tackled by Nolan Carroll. | | |
| NYJ | 1st&10 | NYJ45 | Mark Sanchez pass to the right to Shonn Greene for 6 yards to the Mia49. Tackled by Koa Misi. | | |
| NYJ | 2nd&4 | Mia49 | Bilal Powell rush to the right for 6 yards to the Mia43. Tackled by Cameron Wake. | | |
| NYJ | 1st&10 | Mia43 | Mark Sanchez incomplete pass to the right intended for Jeff Cumberland defensed by Kevin Burnett. | | |
| NYJ | 2nd&10 | Mia43 | Bilal Powell rush to the right for 3 yards to the Mia40. Tackled by Paul Soliai. | | |
| NYJ | 3rd&7 | Mia40 | Mark Sanchez pass to the right to Jeff Cumberland for 19 yards to the Mia21. Tackled by Reshad Jones. | | |
| NYJ | 1st&10 | Mia21 | Shonn Greene rush up the middle for 5 yards to the Mia16. Tackled by Koa Misi. | | |
| NYJ | 2nd&5 | Mia16 | Shonn Greene rush to the left for 1 yard to the Mia15. Tackled by Cameron Wake. | | |
| NYJ | 3rd&4 | Mia15 | Two Minute Warning. | | |
| NYJ | 3rd&4 | Mia15 | Mark Sanchez incomplete pass to the left intended for Stephen Hill. | | |
| NYJ | 4th&4 | Mia15 | Nick Folk 33 yard field goal attempt is GOOD. Holder: Robert Malone. | | |
| NYJ | | | Drive Stats: 16 plays, 67 yards, 6min 36sec | 3 | 10 |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | NYJ | Mia |
| NYJ | | | Nick Folk kicks off to the Mia0. Marcus Thigpen return for 18 yards to Mia13. Tackled by Josh Mauga. Penalty: Illegal Block on Miami (Legedu Naanee) -6 yards. | | |
| Mia | 1st&10 | Mia7 | Reggie Bush rush up the middle for 3 yards to the Mia10. Tackled by David Harris. | | |
| Mia | 2nd&7 | Mia10 | Ryan Tannehill incomplete pass to the right intended for Brian Hartline. | | |
| Mia | 3rd&7 | Mia10 | Reggie Bush rush up the middle for no gain to the Mia10. Tackled by Quinton Coples. Penalty: Unnecessary Roughness on Miami (Jonathan Martin) -5 yards. | | |
| Mia | 4th&12 | Mia5 | New York Jets timeout. | | |
| Mia | 4th&12 | Mia5 | Penalty: Running into Kicker on New York (Eric Smith) 15 yards. | | |
| Mia | 1st&10 | Mia20 | Reggie Bush rush up the middle for 4 yards to the Mia24. Tackled by Bart Scott. | | |
| Mia | 2nd&6 | Mia24 | Miami Dolphins timeout. | | |
| Mia | 2nd&6 | Mia24 | Daniel Thomas rush to the right for 4 yards to the Mia28. Tackled by Muhammad Wilkerson. | | |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | NYJ | Mia |
| |
| Third Quarter |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | NYJ | Mia |
| NYJ | | | Nick Folk kicks off to the Mia0. Marcus Thigpen return for 16 yards to Mia12. Tackled by Nick Bellore. Penalty: Illegal Block on Miami (Troy Nolan) -6 yards. | | |
| Mia | 1st&10 | Mia6 | Daniel Thomas rush to the right for no gain to the Mia6. Tackled by Muhammad Wilkerson. | | |
| Mia | 2nd&10 | Mia6 | Ryan Tannehill pass intended for Anthony Fasano INTERCEPTED by LaRon Landry and returned for 18 yards for a TOUCHDOWN. | | |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | NYJ | Mia |
| NYJ | | | Nick Folk extra point is good. | | |
| NYJ | | | Drive Stats: 0 plays, 0 yards, 0sec | 10 | 10 |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | NYJ | Mia |
| NYJ | | | Nick Folk kicks off to the Mia0. Touchback. | | |
| Mia | 1st&10 | Mia20 | Daniel Thomas rush to the right for 4 yards to the Mia24. Tackled by Kenrick Ellis. FUMBLE, recovered by NYJ (Darrelle Revis). Tackled by Richie Incognito. | | |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | NYJ | Mia |
| NYJ | 1st&10 | Mia26 | Mark Sanchez pass to the right to Santonio Holmes for 13 yards to the Mia13. Tackled by Richard Marshall. | | |
| NYJ | 1st&10 | Mia13 | Shonn Greene rush to the right for no gain to the Mia13. Tackled by Kevin Burnett and Randy Starks. | | |
| NYJ | 2nd&10 | Mia13 | Mark Sanchez pass to the right to Santonio Holmes for 10 yards to the Mia3. Tackled by Richard Marshall. | | |
| NYJ | 1st&3 | Mia3 | Shonn Greene rush to the right for 1 yard to the Mia2. Tackled by Karlos Dansby. | | |
| NYJ | 2nd&2 | Mia2 | Tim Tebow sacked at Mia7 for a loss of 5 yards by Randy Starks. | | |
| NYJ | 3rd&7 | Mia7 | Mark Sanchez pass intended for Stephen Hill INTERCEPTED by Chris Clemons. No return. | | |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | NYJ | Mia |
| Mia | 1st&10 | Mia20 | Lamar Miller rush to the right for 5 yards to the Mia25. Tackled by Sione Po'uha. | | |
| Mia | 2nd&5 | Mia25 | Lamar Miller rush up the middle for 7 yards to the Mia32. Tackled by David Harris. | | |
| Mia | 1st&10 | Mia32 | Daniel Thomas rush to the right for 5 yards to the Mia37. Tackled by Mike DeVito and Calvin Pace. | | |
| Mia | 2nd&5 | Mia37 | Lamar Miller rush to the right for 3 yards to the Mia40. Tackled by Muhammad Wilkerson and Darrelle Revis. | | |
| Mia | 3rd&2 | Mia40 | Lamar Miller rush to the right for 1 yard to the Mia41. Tackled by Bart Scott. | | |
| Mia | 4th&1 | Mia41 | Brandon Fields punts for 59 yards to NYJ0. Touchback. | | |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | NYJ | Mia |
| NYJ | 1st&10 | NYJ20 | Mark Sanchez pass to the left to Santonio Holmes for 8 yards to the NYJ28. Tackled by Richard Marshall. | | |
| NYJ | 2nd&2 | NYJ28 | Shonn Greene rush to the left for a loss of 1 yard to the NYJ27. Tackled by Chris Clemons. | | |
| NYJ | 3rd&3 | NYJ27 | Mark Sanchez incomplete pass to the left intended for Tim Tebow defensed by Reshad Jones. | | |
| NYJ | 4th&3 | NYJ27 | Robert Malone punts for 61 yards to Mia12. Marcus Thigpen return for 8 yards to Mia20. Tackled by Isaiah Trufant. | | |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | NYJ | Mia |
| Mia | 1st&10 | Mia20 | Ryan Tannehill incomplete pass to the right intended for Brian Hartline defensed by Antonio Cromartie. | | |
| Mia | 2nd&10 | Mia20 | Lamar Miller rush to the left for 22 yards to the Mia42. Tackled by Yeremiah Bell. | | |
| Mia | 1st&10 | Mia42 | Lamar Miller rush to the left for no gain to the Mia42. Tackled by Mike DeVito. | | |
| Mia | 2nd&10 | Mia42 | Daniel Thomas rush to the left for 1 yard to the Mia43. Tackled by Muhammad Wilkerson and Yeremiah Bell. | | |
| Mia | 3rd&9 | Mia43 | Ryan Tannehill pass to the left to Daniel Thomas for 11 yards to the NYJ46. Tackled by David Harris. | | |
| Mia | 1st&10 | NYJ46 | Lamar Miller rush up the middle for 6 yards to the NYJ40. Tackled by Quinton Coples. | | |
| Mia | 2nd&4 | NYJ40 | Ryan Tannehill rush to the right for a loss of 3 yards to the NYJ43. Tackled by Bart Scott. | | |
| Mia | 3rd&7 | NYJ43 | Ryan Tannehill pass to the left to Davone Bess for 14 yards to the NYJ29. Tackled by Eric Smith. Penalty: Unnecessary Roughness on New York (Eric Smith) 15 yards. | | |
| Mia | 1st&10 | NYJ14 | Ryan Tannehill pass to the left to Anthony Fasano for 12 yards to the NYJ2. Tackled by Kyle Wilson. | | |
| Mia | 1st&2 | NYJ2 | New York Jets timeout. | | |
| Mia | 1st&2 | NYJ2 | Ryan Tannehill rush to the right for 1 yard to the NYJ1. Tackled by Yeremiah Bell. | | |
| Mia | 2nd&1 | NYJ1 | Jorvorskie Lane rush to the right for 1 yard for a TOUCHDOWN. | | |
| Mia | | | Dan Carpenter extra point is good. | | |
| Mia | | | Drive Stats: 11 plays, 80 yards, 4min 21sec | 10 | 17 |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | NYJ | Mia |
| Mia | | | Dan Carpenter kicks off to the NYJ2. Joe McKnight return for 23 yards to NYJ25. Tackled by Jonathan Freeny. | | |
| NYJ | 1st&10 | NYJ25 | Bilal Powell rush to the right for 4 yards to the NYJ29. Tackled by Randy Starks and Cameron Wake. | | |
| NYJ | 2nd&6 | NYJ29 | Mark Sanchez pass to the right to Jeremy Kerley for 66 yards to the Mia5. Tackled by Sean Smith. | | |
| NYJ | 1st&5 | Mia5 | Shonn Greene rush to the left for 1 yard to the Mia4. Tackled by Richard Marshall. | | |
| |
| Fourth Quarter |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | NYJ | Mia |
| NYJ | 2nd&4 | Mia4 | Penalty: Pass Interference on Miami (Richard Marshall) 3 yards. | | |
| NYJ | 1st&1 | Mia1 | Shonn Greene rush up the middle for no gain to the Mia1. Tackled by Kevin Burnett. | | |
| NYJ | 2nd&1 | Mia1 | Mark Sanchez incomplete pass to the right intended for Jeff Cumberland. | | |
| NYJ | 3rd&1 | Mia1 | Penalty: False Start on New York (Matt Slauson) -5 yards. | | |
| NYJ | 3rd&6 | Mia6 | Mark Sanchez rush to the left for 4 yards to the Mia2. Tackled by Cameron Wake. | | |
| NYJ | 4th&2 | Mia2 | Nick Folk 20 yard field goal attempt is GOOD. Holder: Robert Malone. | | |
| NYJ | | | Drive Stats: 7 plays, 73 yards, 3min 16sec | 13 | 17 |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | NYJ | Mia |
| NYJ | | | Nick Folk kicks off to the Mia0. Marcus Thigpen return for 27 yards to Mia21. Tackled by Josh Bush and Nick Bellore. | | |
| Mia | 1st&10 | Mia21 | Lamar Miller rush to the left for 4 yards to the Mia25. Tackled by David Harris and Garrett McIntyre. | | |
| Mia | 2nd&6 | Mia25 | Lamar Miller rush to the right for no gain to the Mia25. Tackled by Mike DeVito. | | |
| Mia | 3rd&6 | Mia25 | Ryan Tannehill pass to the left to Davone Bess for 20 yards to the Mia45. | | |
| Mia | 1st&10 | Mia45 | Penalty: Pass Interference on New York (Antonio Cromartie) 24 yards. | | |
| Mia | 1st&10 | Mia50 | Penalty: False Start on Miami (John Jerry) -5 yards. | | |
| Mia | 1st&15 | NYJ36 | Penalty: Pass Interference on Miami (Brian Hartline) -10 yards. | | |
| Mia | 1st&25 | NYJ46 | Ryan Tannehill incomplete pass to the right intended for Anthony Armstrong defensed by Ellis Lankster. | | |
| Mia | 2nd&25 | NYJ46 | Ryan Tannehill incomplete pass to the left intended for Anthony Armstrong. | | |
| Mia | 3rd&25 | NYJ46 | Ryan Tannehill pass to the middle to Davone Bess for 17 yards to the NYJ29. Tackled by Ellis Lankster. | | |
| Mia | 4th&8 | NYJ29 | 47 yard field goal attempt by Dan Carpenter is NO GOOD. Holder: Brandon Fields. | | |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | NYJ | Mia |
| NYJ | 1st&10 | NYJ38 | Mark Sanchez incomplete pass to the right intended for Stephen Hill. | | |
| NYJ | 2nd&10 | NYJ38 | Mark Sanchez incomplete pass to the left intended for Bilal Powell. | | |
| NYJ | 3rd&10 | NYJ38 | Mark Sanchez incomplete pass to the right intended for Bilal Powell. | | |
| NYJ | 4th&10 | NYJ38 | Robert Malone punts for 48 yards to Mia14. No return. | | |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | NYJ | Mia |
| Mia | 1st&10 | Mia14 | Ryan Tannehill incomplete pass to the right intended for Brian Hartline. | | |
| Mia | 2nd&10 | Mia14 | Ryan Tannehill incomplete pass to the left intended for Davone Bess defensed by Garrett McIntyre. | | |
| Mia | 3rd&10 | Mia14 | Ryan Tannehill incomplete pass to the left intended for Anthony Armstrong. | | |
| Mia | 4th&10 | Mia14 | Brandon Fields punts for 62 yards to NYJ24. Jeremy Kerley return for 16 yards to NYJ40. Tackled by Olivier Vernon. | | |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | NYJ | Mia |
| NYJ | 1st&10 | NYJ40 | Mark Sanchez incomplete pass to the left intended for Santonio Holmes defensed by Richard Marshall. | | |
| NYJ | 2nd&10 | NYJ40 | Mark Sanchez pass to the left to Santonio Holmes for 18 yards to the Mia42. | | |
| NYJ | 1st&10 | Mia42 | Bilal Powell rush to the right for 5 yards to the Mia37. Tackled by Koa Misi. | | |
| NYJ | 2nd&5 | Mia37 | Joe McKnight rush to the right for a loss of 1 yard to the Mia38. Tackled by Koa Misi. | | |
| NYJ | 3rd&6 | Mia38 | Mark Sanchez incomplete pass to the right intended for Bilal Powell. | | |
| NYJ | 4th&6 | Mia38 | Robert Malone punts for 33 yards to Mia5. No return. | | |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | NYJ | Mia |
| Mia | 1st&10 | Mia5 | Ryan Tannehill pass to the right to Jorvorskie Lane for 1 yard to the Mia6. Tackled by Antonio Cromartie. | | |
| Mia | 2nd&9 | Mia6 | Ryan Tannehill incomplete pass to the right intended for Anthony Fasano. | | |
| Mia | 3rd&9 | Mia6 | Penalty: Delay of Game on Miami (Ryan Tannehill) -3 yards. | | |
| Mia | 3rd&12 | Mia3 | Daniel Thomas rush to the left for 4 yards to the Mia7. Tackled by Yeremiah Bell. | | |
| Mia | 4th&8 | Mia7 | Brandon Fields punts for 57 yards to NYJ36. Jeremy Kerley return for 11 yards to NYJ47. Tackled by Olivier Vernon. | | |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | NYJ | Mia |
| NYJ | 1st&10 | NYJ47 | Mark Sanchez pass to the right to Santonio Holmes for 18 yards to the Mia35. Tackled by Chris Clemons. | | |
| NYJ | 1st&10 | Mia35 | Mark Sanchez incomplete pass to the right intended for Santonio Holmes. | | |
| NYJ | 2nd&10 | Mia35 | Mark Sanchez pass to the left to Bilal Powell for 14 yards to the Mia21. Tackled by Reshad Jones. Penalty: Holding on New York (Santonio Holmes) -10 yards. | | |
| NYJ | 2nd&6 | Mia31 | Mark Sanchez incomplete pass to the right intended for Chaz Schilens. | | |
| NYJ | 3rd&6 | Mia31 | Mark Sanchez pass to the left to Santonio Holmes for 15 yards to the Mia16. Tackled by Chris Clemons. | | |
| NYJ | 1st&10 | Mia16 | Shonn Greene rush to the left for 9 yards to the Mia7. Tackled by Reshad Jones. | | |
| NYJ | 2nd&1 | Mia7 | Shonn Greene rush up the middle for no gain to the Mia7. Tackled by Chris Clemons. | | |
| NYJ | 3rd&1 | Mia7 | New York Jets timeout. | | |
| NYJ | 3rd&1 | Mia7 | Mark Sanchez pass to the middle to Jeremy Kerley for 7 yards for a TOUCHDOWN. | | |
| NYJ | | | Nick Folk extra point is good. | | |
| NYJ | | | Drive Stats: 8 plays, 53 yards, 2min 33sec | 20 | 17 |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | NYJ | Mia |
| NYJ | | | Nick Folk kicks off to the Mia0. Marcus Thigpen return for 31 yards to Mia29. Tackled by Joe McKnight. | | |
| Mia | 1st&10 | Mia29 | Daniel Thomas rush to the right for 3 yards to the Mia32. Tackled by Muhammad Wilkerson. | | |
| Mia | 2nd&7 | Mia32 | Ryan Tannehill pass to the right to Anthony Armstrong for no gain to the Mia32. Tackled by Bart Scott. | | |
| Mia | 3rd&7 | Mia32 | Two Minute Warning. | | |
| Mia | 3rd&7 | Mia32 | Ryan Tannehill pass to the left to Davone Bess for 12 yards to the Mia44. Tackled by Kyle Wilson. | | |
| Mia | 1st&10 | Mia44 | Ryan Tannehill incomplete pass to the left intended for Anthony Armstrong. | | |
| Mia | 2nd&10 | Mia44 | Daniel Thomas rush up the middle for 9 yards to the NYJ47. Tackled by Calvin Pace and Muhammad Wilkerson. | | |
| Mia | 3rd&1 | NYJ47 | Ryan Tannehill rush to the right for 5 yards to the NYJ42. Tackled by Calvin Pace. | | |
| Mia | 1st&10 | NYJ42 | Ryan Tannehill incomplete pass to the middle intended for Anthony Fasano defensed by Eric Smith. | | |
| Mia | 2nd&10 | NYJ42 | Ryan Tannehill incomplete pass to the right intended for Anthony Fasano. | | |
| Mia | 3rd&10 | NYJ42 | Penalty: Pass Interference on New York (Kyle Wilson) 19 yards. | | |
| Mia | 1st&10 | NYJ23 | Ryan Tannehill incomplete pass to the right intended for Anthony Fasano. | | |
| Mia | 2nd&10 | NYJ23 | Ryan Tannehill incomplete pass to the right intended for Brian Hartline. | | |
| Mia | 3rd&10 | NYJ23 | Ryan Tannehill incomplete pass to the right intended for Brian Hartline. | | |
| Mia | 4th&10 | NYJ23 | Dan Carpenter 41 yard field goal attempt is GOOD. Holder: Brandon Fields. | | |
| Mia | | | Drive Stats: 12 plays, 48 yards, 2min 45sec | 20 | 20 |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | NYJ | Mia |
| Mia | | | Dan Carpenter kicks off to the NYJ0. Touchback. | | |
| NYJ | 1st&10 | NYJ20 | Shonn Greene rush up the middle for 2 yards to the NYJ22. Tackled by Karlos Dansby. | | |
| NYJ | 2nd&8 | NYJ22 | Miami Dolphins timeout. | | |
| NYJ | 2nd&8 | NYJ22 | Shonn Greene rush to the right for 3 yards to the NYJ25. Tackled by Cameron Wake. | | |
| NYJ | 3rd&5 | NYJ25 | Miami Dolphins timeout. | | |
| NYJ | 3rd&5 | NYJ25 | Shonn Greene rush to the right for 1 yard to the NYJ26. Tackled by Kevin Burnett and Karlos Dansby. | | |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | NYJ | Mia |
| |
| Overtime |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | NYJ | Mia |
| Mia | | | Dan Carpenter kicks off to the NYJ0. Touchback. | | |
| NYJ | 1st&10 | NYJ20 | Bilal Powell rush to the left for 4 yards to the NYJ24. Tackled by Paul Soliai. | | |
| NYJ | 2nd&6 | NYJ24 | Bilal Powell rush to the left for 11 yards to the NYJ35. Tackled by Reshad Jones. | | |
| NYJ | 1st&10 | NYJ35 | Bilal Powell rush to the right for 4 yards to the NYJ39. Tackled by Koa Misi. | | |
| NYJ | 2nd&6 | NYJ39 | Mark Sanchez incomplete pass to the middle intended for Jeff Cumberland defensed by Richard Marshall. | | |
| NYJ | 3rd&6 | NYJ39 | Mark Sanchez pass to the left to Chaz Schilens for 8 yards to the NYJ47. Tackled by Kevin Burnett. | | |
| NYJ | 1st&10 | NYJ47 | Mark Sanchez incomplete pass to the right intended for Santonio Holmes. | | |
| NYJ | 2nd&10 | NYJ47 | Miami Dolphins timeout. FUMBLE, recovered by NYJ (Mark Sanchez). | | |
| NYJ | 2nd&10 | NYJ47 | Mark Sanchez incomplete pass to the left. | | |
| NYJ | 3rd&10 | NYJ47 | Mark Sanchez pass to the left to Chaz Schilens for 8 yards to the Mia45. Tackled by Olivier Vernon. | | |
| NYJ | 4th&2 | Mia45 | Robert Malone punts for 35 yards to Mia10. No return. | | |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | NYJ | Mia |
| Mia | 1st&10 | Mia10 | Daniel Thomas rush up the middle for 5 yards to the Mia15. Tackled by David Harris. | | |
| Mia | 2nd&5 | Mia15 | Daniel Thomas rush up the middle for 3 yards to the Mia18. Tackled by Bart Scott. | | |
| Mia | 3rd&2 | Mia18 | New York Jets timeout. | | |
| Mia | 3rd&2 | Mia18 | Ryan Tannehill pass to the right to Anthony Fasano for 6 yards to the Mia24. Tackled by Yeremiah Bell. | | |
| Mia | 1st&10 | Mia24 | Ryan Tannehill pass to the right to Brian Hartline for 41 yards to the NYJ35. | | |
| Mia | 1st&10 | NYJ35 | Daniel Thomas rush to the right for 3 yards to the NYJ32. Tackled by Garrett McIntyre. | | |
| Mia | 2nd&7 | NYJ32 | Ryan Tannehill incomplete pass to the left intended for Brian Hartline. | | |
| Mia | 3rd&7 | NYJ32 | Daniel Thomas rush to the right for 2 yards to the NYJ30. Tackled by Muhammad Wilkerson. | | |
| Mia | 4th&5 | NYJ30 | New York Jets timeout. | | |
| Mia | 4th&5 | NYJ30 | 48 yard field goal attempt by Dan Carpenter is NO GOOD. Holder: Brandon Fields. | | |
| Team | Down | Spot | Play | NYJ | Mia |
| NYJ | 1st&10 | NYJ38 | Mark Sanchez pass to the left to Jeff Cumberland for 6 yards to the NYJ44. Tackled by Kevin Burnett. | | |
| NYJ | 2nd&4 | NYJ44 | Mark Sanchez pass to the left to Santonio Holmes for 38 yards to the Mia18. Tackled by Richard Marshall. | | |
| NYJ | 1st&10 | Mia18 | Shonn Greene rush to the left for 5 yards to the Mia13. Tackled by Kevin Burnett. | | |
| NYJ | 2nd&5 | Mia13 | Shonn Greene rush to the right for a loss of 2 yards to the Mia15. Tackled by Koa Misi and Kevin Burnett. | | |
| NYJ | 3rd&7 | Mia15 | Miami Dolphins timeout. | | |
| NYJ | 3rd&7 | Mia15 | Nick Folk 33 yard field goal attempt is GOOD. Holder: Robert Malone. | | |
| NYJ | | | Drive Stats: 5 plays, 47 yards, 1min 49sec | 23 | 20 |